Recital Talk with Sivan Silver-Swartz '15
Senior composition student discusses the creative process and more.
April 18, 2015
Conservatory Communications Staff
Senior recital is a crowning achievement for any conservatory student. We talked about the experience with senior composer Sivan Silver-Swartz' 15.
Could you describe your recital?
My recital is a single piece, a little over an hour long. It鈥檚 for a cello trio and a percussion trio, each in a different room, separated by a hallway. The audience is welcome to walk between the two rooms as they wish throughout the performance. Each performer additionally has a tape player. The tapes that they play have on them the part of the parallel player in the other room鈥攕o, for example, the first cellist has the tape part of the first percussionist and vice versa. The result is that what you hear in one room live and coordinated you hear in the other room on tape and, because of the nature of three tape players playing independently of each other, uncoordinated. The piece itself is composed of a single, monophonic, extended chord progression over the entire piece, on top of which is layered, at certain points, a round (in the sense of an unchanging melody distributed like a canon to the different parts). The essential temporal structural components are exactly the same in both rooms; so when the cellos play a chord, for example, the percussionists at that same point in the score also play a 鈥渢ranslation鈥 of that cello chord into percussion language. That鈥檚 something of a description, at any rate.
What or who inspires you?
I鈥檓 very much inspired by a wide range of composers and music that has to it a certain kind of pacing鈥攁 kind of limitation on what one hears over time: a limitation on the rate of the change in the music and the variety of types of sounds you hear. At some point, about two or three years ago, I became frustrated listening to a lot of music that I felt, in its attempts to be exciting and not lose your attention, moved too quickly. It ended up having the opposite effect for me: I had only started to enjoy the sounds I was hearing before it was all of a sudden on to the next one, which made me want to pay less attention to it. The music of people like Bryn Harrison, Peter Ablinger, Catherine Lamb, Morton Feldman, and Aldo Clementi has influenced me in this regard. Their music, whether it鈥檚 four hours long (as with Feldman鈥檚) or hardly ever longer than 10 minutes (as with Clementi鈥檚), has a kind of focus on the rate of sound that makes, for me, extraordinarily rewarding listening, and so I found I almost couldn鈥檛 not do it in my own music.
Around the same time that I was getting bored with 鈥渆xciting鈥 music, I started getting into just intonation, which the piece on my recital also features. Just intonation is an alternate tuning system based on the overtone series, a series of notes derived from natural acoustical resonance. Basically, we鈥檙e dealing with the infinite number of notes in between the piano keys, and the result of playing in just intonation is a sound world that is both recognizable and unfamiliar. The harmonies you get are, to my ears, stunning and fascinating, harmonies you could never derive from equal temperament (the type of tuning system on a piano and used almost universally everywhere else). People like Marc Sabat, Wolfgang von Schweinitz, Cat Lamb (again), and James Tenney are some of my favorite composers to use just intonation. You may notice that all of these influences are very specific composers鈥擨鈥檓 not saying that such-and-such a novel or political situation or part of nature influenced me. That鈥檚 in part because I鈥檝e been most interested in creating certain specific musical phenomena. They have some connection to other, non-musical interests of mine鈥攐ne big one is the process of assembling the contents of the piece, which is influenced by the aesthetics of information, catalogs, and organization鈥攂ut those interests don鈥檛 necessarily have inherent 鈥渕eaning鈥 outside of my personal predilection to their aesthetic. Someday, perhaps, I would feel comfortable writing a piece 鈥渁bout,鈥 say, some political situation I鈥檓 passionate about. That鈥檚 not today, though.
What strategies do you use to prepare for a big composition?
Start early and work consistently on it. The latter in particular is easier said than done. I鈥檓 a very slow worker when it comes to composition, and often a perfectionist in a kind of debilitating way. I usually just think about what I鈥檓 writing for a while. In this case, it was at least a good month or so before I put down anything resembling (musical) notes, and then probably another two months until I put down a single note with the intention of it being definitely part of the piece. Instead I made a lot of (text) notes and sketches about ideas and tests of different methods and processes I was developing, and figuring out logistical stuff. This is just my way of working, though it鈥檚 much more of a 鈥渢op-down鈥 approach, where I start from the concept of the sounds that I want, an idea of the general aesthetic and process of it in my head, more so than, say, sitting down at a piano and letting sounds I make 鈥渋n the real world鈥 guide the rest of the piece. Often I construct processes that 鈥渨rite themselves鈥濃攖he process is what makes the individual decisions on which exact notes go where, for example. The challenge is to design the process well enough so that it create an end result I like. This means that often I don鈥檛 have a super-precise idea of how it sounds until the process is finished. So I often don鈥檛 work with actually hearing the sounds that the piece makes until a pretty late stage, at which I鈥檓 fiddling with the results that my process created in order to tailor them to what I鈥檓 looking for. At that point, there鈥檚 a lot of writing down of what鈥檚 essentially data I鈥檝e produced, which in this case takes the form of musical notation. I don鈥檛 see the data as something cold and mechanical, though鈥攖he result, I hope, is a world of sound that, because of the process of producing 鈥渄ata,鈥 sounds complex, and rich, and puzzling, and, yes, warm, in a way I couldn鈥檛 have made if I made individual decisions on every single note. When it comes to actually putting on this performance, that comes down to a lot of grunt work. Asking performers if they鈥檙e interested in performing it, coordinating rehearsals and (in this case) recording sessions, and thanking them a million times for their incredible generosity (not to mention their incredible musical talents). Also, scouring eBay for cheap, vintage tape recorders.
What do you hope to be doing 10 years from now?
I have absolutely no idea! I would love to be able to somehow make a career out of composing and/or performing my own music, but that鈥檚 an extremely difficult thing to do. I鈥檝e always made music both in the 鈥減op鈥 world, where you form a band and write songs and perform, and in the 鈥渃lassical鈥 world, where there鈥檚 often a heavier emphasis on notation and the composer as distinct from the performer. I do know that no matter what I do, I don鈥檛 want to give up the other entirely鈥攅ven if I find some success composing experimental classical music for chamber ensembles, I don鈥檛 want to stop playing in and writing songs for a rock band I鈥檓 in, and vice versa. That鈥檚 what I hope to be doing鈥攚hat鈥檚 likely is another question.
You may also like…
Richard Goode鈥檚 Musical Short Stories
The acclaimed pianist returns to the Artist Recital Series on April 29 with the charmingly curated 鈥淔ancies and Goodnights,鈥 along with works by Mozart and Schubert.
91直播 Music Theater Dives into the Upside Down for "Stranger Sings!"
Award-nominated parody delivers "screwy...non-stop fun" revisiting the glorious nostalgia of the 1980s.
No Ordinary Woman: Soprano Katherine Jolly Champions New Music and Womanhood in Art Song
New album by 91直播 associate professor of voice includes three song cycles about womanhood, femininity, and aging gracefully.